Don’t Boycott Israel
The very idea is repellent.
Jack Guez / AFP-Getty Images
If you follow the news closely enough, you might have caught a small item recently noting that Meg Ryan had canceled a scheduled appearance at a film festival in Jerusalem to protest Israeli policy. This was significant not because anyone should care what the nose-crinkling movie star thinks about the Mideast but precisely because no one does. Ryan, a conventional Hollywood Democrat, is a barometer of celebrity politics. Her sort of sheeplike, liberal opinion once reflexively favored Israel. Now it’s dabbling in the repellent idea of shunning the entire country.
Support for the Israeli cultural boycott has been growing in surprising places lately. After the Gaza flotilla incident in June, rock bands including the Pixies canceled performances at a music festival in Tel Aviv. Elvis Costello announced in May that he was canceling two upcoming performances to protest the treatment of Palestinians. Unlike Ryan, Costello is a thoughtful person whose views are worthy of respect. So why, exactly, do I think he’s wrong, too? Why is a private embargo—which includes an academic boycott and the push for divestment on the anti-apartheid model—an unacceptable way for outsiders to protest Israeli treatment of Palestinians?
One argument is that academic boycotts are intrinsically unacceptable because they violate the principles of free expression and the universality of science and learning. A parallel objection applies to cultural boycotts, which directly target the most forward-thinking members of a society. In the case of Israel, shunning writers like Amos Oz and David Grossman, who serve as national consciences, seems not only intrinsically vile but actively counterproductive. On the other hand, it would be hard to justify a blanket rule that cultural and academic sectors are always off-limits. In authoritarian societies, cultural institutions do tend to become ideological proxies—think of the National Ballet in Cuba, or the East German gymnastics team.
An even weaker case against the cultural boycott is that it’s unlikely to work. While it’s certainly true that cultural sanctions on their own are more inconvenience than lethal weapon, they can have a real impact. In South Africa, cultural and, in particular, sports sanctions—banning the country from the Olympics and from international cricket and rugby competitions—were an effective form of pressure. When it comes to Israel, it’s hard to predict what effect cultural and academic isolation might have. Some Israelis take international rejection as an affirmation, concluding that amid a sea of hostility their only recourse is self-sufficiency. On the other hand, opponents of the Netanyahu government cite global opprobrium as an argument for a different political course.
Perhaps boycotts should be off-limits as a tactic against democratic societies, where other means of peaceful protest exist. But here, too, it’s hard to come up with a blanket rule. The immediate resort to sanctions when an elected government—say, Arizona’s—does something objectionable seems extreme and disproportionate. Yet an elected democracy like the Milosevic regime in Serbia can oppress ethnic minorities or commit genocide as well as an unelected one. And, indeed, one could argue that only in a democracy are the people truly responsible for the actions of their government.
The stronger case against a cultural boycott of Israel is based on consistency, proportionality, and history. That supporters of this boycott seldom focus on China or Syria or Zimbabwe—or other genuinely illegitimate regimes that systematically violate human rights—underscores their bad faith. Boycotters are not trying to send the specific message, “We object to your settlement policy in the West Bank.” What they’re saying is, “We consider your country so intrinsically reprehensible that we are going to treat all of your citizens as pariahs.” Like the older Arab economic boycott of Israel, which dates back to the 1940s, the cultural boycott is a weapon designed not to bring peace but to undermine the country.
Because Israel is a refuge for Jews persecuted everywhere else, this kind of existential challenge is hard to disassociate from anti-Semitism—even if Ryan and Costello intend nothing of the kind. When people are trying to murder you because of your religion, it is difficult to credit the bona fides of those who merely want to shun you because of your government.
Facebook Tweet Digg print email comments Your Email
Their Email
Cancel Email Sent Unable to Send Email Invalid Email Address Next: Afghanistan Wants to See the Money »
More on Newsweek
The New 'Mad Men' Likes It Rough 10 Ways Facebook Can Ruin Your Life $13/Month Car Insurance?
Insurance deal just passed now allows you to get car insurance for $13
CarInsuranceFinder.orgThree-bureau credit monitoring
Monitor your credit and get 3 credit scores Free!
Equifax.comHillsboro: Mom turns $97 into $6,012
Sounds Impossible? That’s what we thought until we heard her…
news10reports.com
Use my avatar from...
No avatar
My computer
My Facebook Profile
My Google Profile
My Twitter Account
My FriendFeed Account
My Yahoo! Account
Gravatar email
Login
Login with:
My Facebook Profile
My Google Profile
My Twitter Account
My FriendFeed Account
My Yahoo! Account
My Blogger Account
My JS-Kit Account
My Haloscan Account
My OpenID
Login required, click here to begin
Share
Share with:
This Page
My Facebook Friends
My Google Friends
My Twitter Followers
My FriendFeed Followers
My Yahoo! Friends
This Page
Follow
Leave a comment@Controls
Comments 451 ItemsAdmin
Log In
Follow
Moderation
General Settings
Admin Notices
– Ira
Is Jacob Weisberg the voice of Newsweek? We know Jacob Weisberg is a pro-Israel reporter and has always been. We never heard him defending Palestinian people against Israel's oppression. Where is he when innocent Palestinians are killed by Israel army? If Newsweek stands by his reporter then I don't have other choice than canceling my Newsweek Subscription.
Today, 11:24:38 PM– Flag – Like – Reply – Delete – Edit – Moderate kittycat
I see Newsweek/Weisberg still have not corrected their flawed story. Oh well, I'll just repeat what I said before untill they do rectify.
FYI Newsweek people: Meg Ryan never accepted an invitation to attend the Jerusalem Film Festival. So claiming she cancelled her appearance is nonsense. It seems mr Weisberg never bothered to fact-check his story.
Fortunatly, his collegue from the Jewish Journal DID check the story and guess what: it was false. You can read about it here: http://www.jewishjournal.com/rob_eshman/article/agent_questions_20100720/
Turns out some 'official' working for the film festival made false claims about both Meg Ryan and Dustin Hoffman.
So what boycot, mister Weisberg? Why the uncalled for and childish name-calling? Do you have a problem with women in general?
Today, 10:13:58 PM– Flag – Like – Reply – Delete – Edit – Moderate ex mea sententia
"Because Israel is a refuge for Jews persecuted everywhere else, this kind of existential challenge is hard to disassociate from anti-Semitism—even if Ryan and Costello intend nothing of the kind. When people are trying to murder you because of your religion, it is difficult to credit the bona fides of those who merely want to shun you because of your government."
Nice use of the Al Sharpton defense. I guess Israel is free to do what it pleases because if I dare criticize its actions, I might risk appearing as an anti-Semitic Jew hater. Mr. Weisberg you're a smart man and you know better. I suggest (although you probably are not reading this and I am wasting my time) that next time you do not rely on such a crutch. As you would say, "the very idea is repellent."
The argument that because these people don't boycott China, Zimbabwe, or Syria, they should not boycott Israel is interesting. It is often proudly proclaimed that Israel is the only democracy and free and open society in the middle east. Yet it is to be held to the same low standard as China, a communist country, Zimbabwe, or Syria?
As Peter Beinart would say, you check your liberal ideology at Zionism's door.
Today, 10:10:07 PM– Flag – Like – Reply – Delete – Edit – Moderate Paul
The idea that the majority cannot oppress a minority just because the government is democratic is frankly stupid. Were a democratic nation today to allow slavery, any sort of boycott, political pressure, or other non-violent means of underscoring our disapproval would be absolutely justified.
Argue such ideas on the merits of the need for change. It is stupid to claim that the idea of a boycott is a bad idea solely because a nation is democratic.
Today, 9:33:52 PM– Flag – Like – Reply – Delete – Edit – Moderate Jim
When will we Americans realize the heavy price we paid for our support of Israel? Al Qaida attacked us on 9/11 primarily because of our support of Israel. You don't have to take my word. Just listed to the many tapes released by Bin Laden himself. After 9/11, jewish journalists like Jeff Goldberg, Charles Krauthammer, Safire, Bill Kristol, and other jews engaged in a non-stop propaganda that the Arabs hate us because of our freedom. These Jewish journalists conspired with Richard Perle, Douglas Feith, Wolfowitz and other members of the Jewish Lobby to force America to go to war against Iraq, a country which posed no threat to America. The jews were pushing for the Iraq war for the sole benefit of Israel, which resulted in the death of more than 4000 troops. Now the same gang is pushing us to attack Iran, again for the sole benefit of Israel. When are we Americans going to stand up and say NO!
Today, 9:23:08 PM– Flag – Like – Reply – Delete – Edit – Moderate
More
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment