Friday, October 24, 2014

Plutocrats Against Democracy

Continue reading the main storyShare This Page
It’s always good when leaders tell the truth, especially if that wasn’t their intention. So we should be grateful to Leung Chun-ying, the Beijing-backed leader of Hong Kong, for blurting out the real reason pro-democracy demonstrators can’t get what they want: With open voting, “You would be talking to half of the people in Hong Kong who earn less than $1,800 a month. Then you would end up with that kind of politics and policies” — policies, presumably, that would make the rich less rich and provide more aid to those with lower incomes.
So Mr. Leung is worried about the 50 percent of Hong Kong’s population that, he believes, would vote for bad policies because they don’t make enough money. This may sound like the 47 percent of Americans who Mitt Romney said would vote against him because they don’t pay income taxes and, therefore, don’t take responsibility for themselves, or the 60 percent that Representative Paul Ryan argued pose a danger because they are “takers,” getting more from the government than they pay in. Indeed, these are all basically the same thing.
For the political right has always been uncomfortable with democracy. No matter how well conservatives do in elections, no matter how thoroughly free-market ideology dominates discourse, there is always an undercurrent of fear that the great unwashed will vote in left-wingers who will tax the rich, hand out largess to the poor, and destroy the economy.
In fact, the very success of the conservative agenda only intensifies this fear. Many on the right — and I’m not just talking about people listening to Rush Limbaugh; I’m talking about members of the political elite — live, at least part of the time, in an alternative universe in which America has spent the past few decades marching rapidly down the road to serfdom. Never mind the new Gilded Age that tax cuts and financial deregulation have created; they’re reading books with titles like “A Nation of Takers: America’s Entitlement Epidemic,” asserting that the big problem we have is runaway redistribution.
This is a fantasy. Still, is there anything to fears that economic populism will lead to economic disaster? Not really. Lower-income voters are much more supportive than the wealthy toward policies that benefit people like them, and they generally support higher taxes at the top. But if you worry that low-income voters will run wild, that they’ll greedily grab everything and tax job creators into oblivion, history says that you’re wrong. All advanced nations have had substantial welfare states since the 1940s — welfare states that, inevitably, have stronger support among their poorer citizens. But you don’t, in fact, see countries descending into tax-and-spend death spirals — and no, that’s not what ails Europe.
Still, while the “kind of politics and policies” that responds to the bottom half of the income distribution won’t destroy the economy, it does tend to crimp the incomes and wealth of the 1 percent, at least a bit; the top 0.1 percent is paying quite a lot more in taxes right now than it would have if Mr. Romney had won. So what’s a plutocrat to do?
One answer is propaganda: tell voters, often and loudly, that taxing the rich and helping the poor will cause economic disaster, while cutting taxes on “job creators” will create prosperity for all. There’s a reason conservative faith in the magic of tax cuts persists no matter how many times such prophecies fail (as is happening right now in Kansas): There’s a lavishly funded industry of think tanks and media organizations dedicated to promoting and preserving that faith.
Another answer, with a long tradition in the United States, is to make the most of racial and ethnic divisions — government aid just goes to Those People, don’t you know. And besides, liberals are snooty elitists who hate America.
A third answer is to make sure government programs fail, or never come into existence, so that voters never learn that things could be different.
But these strategies for protecting plutocrats from the mob are indirect and imperfect. The obvious answer is Mr. Leung’s: Don’t let the bottom half, or maybe even the bottom 90 percent, vote.
And now you understand why there’s so much furor on the right over the alleged but actually almost nonexistent problem of voter fraud, and so much support for voter ID laws that make it hard for the poor and even the working class to cast ballots. American politicians don’t dare say outright that only the wealthy should have political rights — at least not yet. But if you follow the currents of thought now prevalent on the political right to their logical conclusion, that’s where you end up.
The truth is that a lot of what’s going on in American politics is, at root, a fight between democracy and plutocracy. And it’s by no means clear which side will win.

Tuesday, October 14, 2014

the CCP is impatient with the protesters.

The clampdown comes amid increasing impatience in Beijing over the political crisis in the semi-autonomous Chinese territory.
A front-page editorial Wednesday in the People's Daily, the ruling Communist Party's mouthpiece, condemned the protests and said "they are doomed to fail."
"Facts and history tell us that radical and illegal acts that got their way only result in more severe illegal activities, exacerbating disorder and turmoil," the commentary said, referring to the activists.
"Stability is bliss, and turmoil brings havoc," it said.

Wednesday, October 1, 2014

The rounding up of activists in mainland China only underlines why so many people in Hong Kong fear the growing control Beijing has in their city’s affairs.”

China Restricts Travel to Hong Kong

29

Oct. 1 is officially known as National Day in China, the anniversary of the founding of the People’s Republic of China. Unofficially, Oct.1 is the first day of “Gold Week,” which means a time for shopping, which means Hong Kong for those in mainland China.
Gold Week this year is getting a straightened observance in Hong Kong, as Beijing is trying to keep mainland tourists at home. The views of Mr. Chen help explain why.
Epoch Times caught up with Mr. Chen along with his mother, wife, and son in the Admiralty district of Hong Kong, ground zero for the Occupy Central protests for universal suffrage that are convulsing the city. 
“We came here just to let our child to see what democracy is. We hope he can also fight for democracy in the future.” Mr. Chen said, “Hong Kong is a democratic society with the rule of law. The Communist Party can’t deal with things recklessly.”
Beijing is treating sentiments like Mr. Chen’s like a contagion that needs to be quarantined. Authorities are blocking both regular media and social media from carrying information about Occupy Central, arresting mainland Chinese who express online support for the movement, and restricting travel to Hong Kong.
A photo published on Chinese social media shows five mainland Chinese in black shirts holding a banner with the slogan "Fight For Freedom Support Hong Kong Occupy Central." In the last two days, China has detained at least 20 people in the mainland who have spread information about Occupy Central or posted supportive comments on the Internet, Amnesty International said on Oct. 1, 2014.(Screenshot/Sound of Hope)
A photo published on Chinese social media shows five mainland Chinese in black shirts holding a banner with the slogan “Fight For Freedom Support Hong Kong Occupy Central.” In the last two days, China has detained at least 20 people in the mainland who have spread information about Occupy Central or posted supportive comments on the Internet, Amnesty International said on Oct. 1, 2014.(Screenshot/Sound of Hope)

Arrested

Although China has strengthened its internet censorship, information about Occupy Central has still leaked to mainland China, and many Chinese people are showing their support on the Internet for Occupy Central. Officials are hot on the trail of sympathizers, though, and there have been reports of dozens of arrests. 
According to Amnesty International on Wednesday, at least 20 people have been detained by police in the last 2 days in different cities in mainland China for online posts showing support for Hong Kong protesters, or for planning to travel to Hong Kong to join the movement. 
Another 60 people have been summoned by police for their online comments about Hong Kong. 
Han Ying posted a photo on the popular messaging platform called We Chat showing five mainland Chinese in her home wearing black t-shirts and holding a banner saying “Fight For Freedom Support Hong Kong’s Occupy Central.”
Four of those pictured had shaved heads. In early September, the founders of Occupy Central shaved their heads in a show of determination, and the mainlanders’ shaved heads appear to be an imitation of that.
Han was summoned by the Beijing police for the alleged crime of “defiance and quarreling,” after this photo and other messages by him about Hong Kong appeared. 
China researcher at Amnesty International William Nee said on Monday, “The rounding up of activists in mainland China only underlines why so many people in Hong Kong fear the growing control Beijing has in their city’s affairs.”
“The Chinese authorities must immediately release all those being detained for peacefully expressing their support for protesters in Hong Kong,” Nee said.  

Travel Restrictions

Authorities have sought to ban the group tours popular to Hong Kong at this time of year.
A Netizen with the “Big talk of Wuhu” published on Weibo, a twitter-like platform in China, “Tourism Bureau of Wuhu City [of eastern China's Anhui Province] received a note from the provincial tourism bureau that all local travel agencies are not allowed to organize tourist groups to Hong Kong until after Oct. 7.” 
“The tourist groups to Hong Kong that are already organized can continue to go, but make sure to give warning and education to tourists in advance to not go to protest areas or watch the gatherings.” the note says. 
Another similar note issued in southwestern China’s Yunnan Province was also leaked on Twitter on Sept. 30. User @HKsfl posted a photo of the note titled “emergency notice” with a stamp of Yunnan Provincial Tourism Development Commission, saying, “Due to Hong Kong’s Occupy Central movement, all tourist companies are not allowed to organize tourist groups to Hong Kong from today.”
A group of mainland Chinese show support for Hong Kong's Occupy Central by holding banners at home, which says "Hold tight to freedom in wind and rain. We support Hong Kong!" In the past two days China has detained at least 20 people in mainland who spread information about Occupy Central or posted supportive comments on the internet, Amnesty International said on Oct. 1, 2014.(Screenshot/Sound of Hope)
A group of mainland Chinese show support for Hong Kong’s Occupy Central by holding banners at home, which says “Hold tight to freedom in wind and rain. We support Hong Kong!”(Screenshot/Sound of Hope)

Mainlanders Support

Mr. Hu from Hangzhou City of eastern China’s Zhejiang Province has been donating food and living supplies to protesters in recent days, according to Apple Daily in Hong Kong. 
Mr. Hu indicated that the Occupy Central is a big inspiration for mainland young people, because many of them worship money, are selfish, and lack national consciousness.
On Wednesday, young man who identified himself as from the mainland went to Hong Kong’s Mongkok district, where many protesting students have gathered. Although he wore a mask and didn’t divulge his identity fearing retaliation from the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) upon his return home, he gave a speech on stage. 
He praised the protesters for being so peaceful and rational, unlike, he said, how the CCP’s propaganda had portrayed them, as “a riot.” 
With reporting by Wang Wenjun and Wen Hanlin.